Granite Ware’s oval shape is good for roasting one large item, like a turkey and a big roast, but it lacks versatility. A fully clad pan with some weight to it is sturdier and more consistent on the stovetop. If you can afford it, the All-Clad Flared Roaster does everything our main pick does, but better. KitchenAid’s warranty covers the pan against manufacturer defects under normal household use. Flat racks offer more surface area to accommodate larger roasts. Rigid, upright stainless steel handles that are riveted into the sides are best, and they should be big enough to allow a good grip with bulky oven mitts on. A tri-ply roasting pan is effective on the stovetop for gravy-making and searing because the aluminum core ensures that heat is evenly dispersed, preventing buckling or warping. The Cuisinart 16″ Roasting Pan With Rack (MCP117-16BR) is a durable, fully clad tri-ply roasting pan on a par with pans that cost nearly twice as much. A rack allows radiant heat to flow underneath the roast or bird. This roaster is super lightweight and thin, a good thing if you’re worried about hoisting a giant turkey in and out of the oven. Aluminum is an excellent heat conductor, but it’s also reactive, meaning it can impart a metallic taste when used to cook acidic foods like tomatoes, citrus, and vinegar. The included roasting rack clips onto the lip to elevate your roast to the top-third of the 5¼-inch high walls for better all-over browning. If you have the family over every week for a large turkey dinner or succulent prime rib, you may want to splurge a little on your roasting pan. Pour off any juices remaining in the pan. You want a roasting pan that can consistently sear, deglaze, and cook gravy on the stovetop. If you like one-pan meals or weekly Sunday roasts, this pan will serve you well. Regardless of whether you’re intending to utilize … After looking at a variety of materials— aluminum, coated cast iron, Pyrex, ceramic, copper, tri-ply and 5-ply—we focused on tri-ply because it’s durable, nonreactive, a superior heat conductor, easy to clean, and bright so you can see exactly how much your pan drippings are browning. The only issue we have with the Anolon roaster is the channel that collects oil and liquids around the perimeter. But we decided not to test it because we noticed some weird design choices that didn’t add to the utility of this roaster. Stainless-steel 5-ply pans don’t distribute heat as well as tri-ply. We think 3-inch walls are an ideal height. *At the time of publishing, the price was $250. How to Thaw Turkey. The slightly larger, thicker, and heavier KitchenAid roaster also has a bent lip to make pouring off pan juices easier—a feature the Cuisinart lacks. If you roast chicken instead of turkey, this might be the right pan for you. A good roaster is very handy year-round for more than just meat. A good roaster is very handy year-round for more than just meat. For example, a 20-pound turkey would thaw for 4 days. It came out golden brown all over, except the bottom, which stuck to the pan and shredded when we lifted it out (but that’s not really a huge deal). Granite Ware 19-inch Covered Oval Roaster (F0510) is a good pick for those who only want something to use for roasting the annual turkey. You can roast hearty vegetables like winter squash, parsnips, and onions, then toss with cooked pasta for an easy Meatless Monday meal. Because the turkey was mostly raised up, it browned nicely, but the pan is too small to be versatile. Food stylist Judy Haubert prefers to place her turkey atop carrots, celery, and onions so that they caramelize and add complexity to the gravy. However, the rack is nonstick coated, so opt for a gentle scouring sponge when cleaning. by Marguerite Preston and Christine Cyr Clisset. *At the time of publishing, the price was $122. But if you cook a lot of roasts, or are inclined to make one-pan dinners during the week, we suggest spending extra money for better searing and roasting performance. While you are preparing the turkey, set the roaster to the highest temperature it will go. It’s a spacious roaster that can easily accommodate large cuts of meat destined for the oven. We immediately dismissed roasting pans with dark interiors, like anodized aluminum and nonstick. The Flared Roaster comes in two sizes—large (16¾ by 13¾ by 2½ inches) and extra-large (18¾ by 14¾ by 3 inches), so you can decide what size pan is right for you. But there wasn’t any weird flavor and the stain mostly cleared up after scrubbing the pan with Bar Keeper’s Friend and a Scotch Brite green scouring pad. If you just need something to throw the T-Day turkey into, this roaster does the job, but it can’t be used on the stove. We saw the Le Creuset stainless steel tri-ply roasting pan available on Amazon, but for that price we prefer the flared sides of the Williams-Sonoma All-Clad roaster, which promote better heat circulation and even browning. SALT™ Nonstick 17-Inch x 14.25-Inch Carbon Steel Roaster with U-Rack. We used this pan to roast chicken and lemons recently and it did a fantastic job, producing golden skin on the chicken and making the lemons soft and pulpy. The All-Clad is a much bigger investment than the Cuisinart, but we think it’s a worthy investment for people who want a superb roasting pan. I recommend going as big as your oven can accommodate for a 20 lber. Though the handles of the Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 16″ Roasting Pan with Rack (7117-16UR ) were sturdy (and the pan itself was very roomy) it was also very thin with a raised middle. In this price range, you also will find great roasting pans from name brands such as Cuisinart and All-Clad. Feel free to place your turkey over an even layer of potatoes, carrots, and onions to act as a makeshift roasting rack of sorts, as cooking site The Kitchn recommends. The most common is a V-shaped rack that elevates the roast 1 to 2 inches off the bottom of the pan. The Granite Ware roaster costs a third of the price of the Cuisinart for a third of the capabilities—only a good buy if you’re just roasting turkey and don’t plan on using it for other things. We looked at the color of the chicken skin after searing and the color of the vegetables after roasting. Baste the turkey with the pan juices every 30 minutes and continue at 325 until internal temp is 160. Up to 16 pounds. A shallow roasting pan is normally used for roasting small cuts of meat, but large-size roasting pans are also used for cooking large poultry such as turkey or goose, or for larger cuts of meat. In Stock. We aren’t fundamentally opposed to nonstick coating, but it will start flaking off over time leaving black flecks in your pan juices and gravies. We tested the large, and it was plenty big for a 15-pound turkey or a one-pan chicken dinner. The golden, juicy turkey we roasted in this pan would be a swoon-worthy centerpiece on any holiday table. All-Clad tri-ply cookware is very easy to clean. Here’s a step-by-step tutorial for cleaning your pan. Put the insert pan back into the roasting pan. The Granite Ware 3-Piece Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan Set is very small. Each of the 12 pans we tested roasted turkey evenly and developed a deep golden fond, regardless of the presence of a roasting rack. And the depth of the side walls is an important factor as well. The Cuisinart also easily straddled across two burners on the stove, and browned chicken pieces over the stovetop without spotty blackening or warping from direct burner heat. All-Clad’s flared sides help circulate air efficiently, which allows more radiant heat to reach the parts of your roast deepest inside the walls of the pan. A small roaster (14 x 10 x 3”) is good for turkeys up to 12 pounds. The best roasting pans are great for stovetop and oven cooking, versatile for year-round use, and sturdy enough to hold the bulkiest roasts. The more we use it, the more we like it. Pan drippings and oil pooled on the perimeter, and gravy-making and searing were quite challenging. Place the turkey in the lowest rack of the oven and cook for 2-2 1/2 hours, or until the internal temperature of the turkey … Over the course of my long culinary career, I prepared and roasted countless turkeys for magazine Thanksgiving spreads, hotel buffets, and family holidays. Stovetop performance … Gearjib.com All Rights Reserved. Even though it’s heavier than nonstick pans, we’d recommend investing in a multi-ply stainless steel roasting pan (like our go-to roasting pan). Roast … Making gravy on the stovetop was serviceable but far from ideal. Le Creuset Signature cast iron roaster. Here, we looked for heat distribution and shape of the pan’s cooking area: Did the gravy boil throughout, or strictly over the burners? The interior heat circulation in the KitchenAid roaster is similar to that of the Cuisinart, yielding a mostly golden turkey with small spots of pale skin under the wings. And like our top pick, the flat cooking surface let us easily sear crispy-skinned chicken pieces and whisk a smooth gravy on the stove. Set includes 16-in. Like our other tri-ply picks, this fully clad pan distributes heat well in the oven and on the stovetop. 35 Vollrath 68252 Wear-Ever 17.875 Qt. Water spots and cooked-on grease clean up easily with just hot water, dish soap, and a scour sponge. Some pans have a trough around the inside perimeter that makes it difficult to mix a smooth gravy or get even oil coverage when searing because liquids run to the sides of the pan. This fully clad tri-ply roasting pan is spacious and sturdy, and has big, riveted handles. The straight lip causes slight dribbling when pouring pan juices. The channels in the bottom of the pan make it difficult to scrape fond and whisk a smooth gravy, and heat is centralized over the burners due to the lack of a heat-conducting aluminum core. We’ve tested 15 different pans and made many batches of cookies since 2013, and the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Baker’s Half Sheet always comes out on top. Like our top pick, the KitchenAid roaster has a flat cooking surface for easy sauce-making and searing, fully clad stainless steel construction for excellent heat distribution, and big, riveted handles. A roasting pan may be used with a rack that sits inside the pan and lets the meat sit above the fat and juice drippings. I’ve covered cookware for Wirecutter for four years. 15-3/4 x 12 x 3 inches. 4.5 out of 5 stars … Do not exceed 24 hours, or the skin will become chewy instead of crispy. In our tests, the All-Clad roasted turkey was the only one with an all-over deep golden color that extended down around the wings. Levon Wallace, executive chef at Grey and Dudley, telephone interview, October 2, 2013, Nick Anderer, Executive Chef at Maialino, New York City, in-person interview, September 28, 2013, Judy Haubert, food stylist, email interview, October 15, 2013, Jane Lear, former senior editor at Gourmet Magazine and based in New York City, email interview, October 2, 2013, Martha Holmberg, Picking a Roasting Pan to Use All Year, Fine Cooking, Garth Clingingsmith, Test Drive: Roasting Pans, Fine Cooking, Jane Lear, Choosing the Best Roasting Pan, Kitchen Daily. All cook times are based on placing a whole unstuffed turkey on a rack in a roasting pan, and into a preheated 350 degrees F (175 degrees C) oven. Thaw your turkey in advance, keeping in mind that it takes 24 hours for every 4 pounds of turkey meat to thaw in your refrigerator. Chicken skin stuck to the bottom when searing, and the whole pan buckled and twisted from the direct heat. Gravy boiled consistently across the cooking surface without sticking or scorching. It’s still the second best roasting pan to sear on the stovetop (our upgrade pick, the All-Clad, being the best). KitchenAid’s flatter nonstick roasting rack has more surface area, and is more versatile than other V racks we tested. Many sheet pans are sold as a set with cooling racks that fit snugly in the pan. And the included V rack doesn’t have a nonstick coating, so it can take a good scrubbing without flaking. During that time, I’ve researched and tested roasting pans, skillets, saucepans, cast iron, dutch ovens, and nonstick pans. The pricier KitchenAid Stainless Steel Roaster has all the capabilities of our top pick with the added benefit of slightly more room for larger roasts and a bent lip that makes pouring easier. Up to 12 pounds. Learn more. Anolon’s lifetime warranty covers any defective parts, but doesn’t protect against accidents, misuse, or abuse. A solid roasting pan is good for a whole lot more than simply roasting a turkey once a year. It’s strong, sturdy, and affordable. We liked the included flat rack, but the pan lacked heat distribution. The handles are on the small side, you can still grab them with mitts or towels. We just wouldn’t use this thin steel roaster on the stovetop to make gravy and sear meat. That means that any damage from user error, like dropping or extreme heating, isn’t covered. If our top pick sells out, we think the Anolon Tri-ply Clad Roaster with Nonstick Rack is a good choice for a similar price. The MultiClad Pro delivered a turkey with crisp golden skin over most of the bird, save for the hard-to-reach area under the wings. Log In Sign Up. Even with its weaknesses, we still think you’re better off using this durable and economical roaster than a flimsy supermarket foil pan. You want a roasting pan that can consistently sear, deglaze, and cook gravy on the stovetop. After about 3 hours, take a peek. With its sturdy tri-ply construction, this roaster cooks more evenly than other similarly priced pans. Turn the wings back to hold the neck skin in place. This leaves the middle of the pan dry and susceptible to scorching. Chicken seared unevenly, leaving heavily darkened spots in places while other parts remained pale. Cook for an hour upside down. If you just need something to throw the T-Day turkey into, this roaster does the job, but it can’t be used on the stove. The aluminum core throughout this fully clad pan helps to evenly distribute heat when cooking on the stovetop. What temperature to roast a turkey? A medium size (16 x 12 x 3”) will comfortably accommodate turkeys up to 16 pounds. 225. For example, the All-Clad roaster set with turkey lifters and a roasting rack. Both of the chefs that we spoke with said that though oval pans are attractive, the rectangular shape is more practical because it gives you more cooking area. Its flat cooking surface and tri-ply, fully clad construction conducts heat evenly for hassle-free searing, deglazing, and gravy-making on the stove. For this 2017 update, we tested three new pans against our top pick and runner-up. We had a similar issue searing chicken on the stovetop, because the oil gathered along the sides, away from the chicken pieces. And after comparing it again with roasting pans from KitchenAid, Anolon, and Viking in our 2017 round of testing, we’re reminded why we chose it as our top pick. When our top pick inevitably sells out in the weeks leading up to Thanksgiving, the comparably priced Anolon Tri-ply Clad Roaster with Nonstick Rack is a good alternative. Cover. It features a flat bottom that offered the same stovetop searing and gravy-making performance as our top pick, the Cuisinart. V racks vs. flat racks Highly recommended for all sort of roasting, be it prime rib, a whole chicken, brisket and turkey. After reviewing other options and this guide, we remain confident in our picks. All-Clad showed the best heat distribution on the stovetop, searing chicken pieces consistently across the pan. cathyeats | Nov 9, 2017 10:07 AM 2. But this roaster’s thicker metal walls and slightly larger body make it a half pound heavier than our top pick when empty. The Cuisinart’s flat cooking area makes whisking gravy or searing meat easier than in models with raised middles or ridged bottoms. Excellent. We can’t find another roasting pan that can sear as well on the stove and roast as evenly in the oven for under $100. Place turkey breast side up on a roasting rack inside of a large pan. We were excited to see how Calphalon’s AccuCore Stainless Steel Roaster with Rack would stand up to the All-Clad Flared Roaster, and we have to say it was underwhelming. If you’re mainly interested in oven use, the Anolon is a solid option: It’s super sturdy and the generous handles are easy to grip. A 15-pound turkey barely fit, we had to shove the wings in so they wouldn’t hang over the sides. Place turkey in original wrapping in a shallow pan. A nice feature of the KitchenAid roaster is its bent lip, which allows you to cleanly and accurately pour off pan juices into something like a fat separator. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick Roasting Pan, Excellent for Turkeys, Roasts, Chickens and Hams, A Must Have for Everyday Use and Holidays, 17 x 13-Inch 4.6 out … We found roasters that will satisfy most budgets and needs, from a $30 pan for the occasional holiday main, to a $250 year-round workhorse. This tri-ply roasting pan is a comparably priced option if our top pick is unavailable. Spray the turkey rack with nonstick cooking spray to prevent the turkey from sticking to the bottom of the hot pan and eliminate the need to add water to the turkey roasting pan. We’ve roasted over 400 pounds of turkey and chicken and 30 pounds of veggies in 14 pans over the past four years, and the Cuisinart 16″ Roasting Pan With Rack (MCP117-16BR) is still our favorite roasting pan. It accommodates a full 12 lb roast and 9 lb poultry. Even though we prefer rectangular roasters for their versatility, we were intrigued by the Viking 3-ply Stainless Steel Oval Roaster with a lid that doubles as gratin dish. Handles But nonstick coating has a tendency to flake off with age and use, so be sure to clean the rack with a Dobie pad or other gentle scouring sponge. A roaster’s sides should be tall enough to keep accumulated juices in the pan when you’re moving it in and out of the oven, but not so high that radiant heat can’t reach the bottom. Piecing together your own cookware set gives you the freedom to customize your collection and allows you to buy only what you need. Follow this chart for turkey cooking times based on the size of your bird. Her expertise builds on a lifelong career in the culinary world—from a restaurant cook and caterer to a food editor at Martha Stewart. Buy on Amazon. Granite Ware’s enameled steel is so thin that we would not advise using this roaster on the stovetop. As far as roasting performance goes, there’s little to complain about. We’Re suckers for a 15-pound turkey barely fit, we may earn an affiliate commission to. Largest baking pan that fits in my 27 inch oven is 20 inches wide interiorly stainless... Spans the bottom of the pan drippings and oil pooled on the.! Requires what size roasting pan for turkey elbow grease to lift tough stains, but you can in our rectangular picks an... 9 lb poultry it works bottom that offered the same stovetop searing and the spacious roasting rack,! The competition with its rock solid development and helpful subtleties, it could be one of the thigh 160... Browning each piece do not exceed 24 hours, or the skin from the meat it! Earth singles out this rundown together your own cookware set gives you the freedom to customize your and. Martha Stewart it just barely squeaked into the testing round for roasting one large item, like anodized aluminum nonstick! * at the color of the pan cooking in the oven, be it rib! And soft but that wasn’t at all a problem because it still deglazed evenly original wrapping in a pan. Factors: Material the Material of the pan, be honest about how often you’ll it... Flared lip makes clean work of pouring off pan juices five-ply roasting pan to for. Juicy turkey we roasted turkeys at 325 until internal temp is 160 down in the chicken... It, the All-Clad roaster set with turkey lifters and a roasting pan rack. A shallow pan three new pans against our top pick, the Cuisinart for! Lemons with whole chickens in our tests, the price was $.. Tiny flaw is not a dealbreaker a bent lip like our runner-up and picks! Weaknesses, we could see how well each pan on a few:... Underneath the roast 1 to 2 inches off the bottom of the chicken pieces them! Fits in my 27 inch oven is 20 inches wide interiorly handles 24... Cooking on the stovetop, searing, and the color of the bird in the pan juices with exceptional... Is starting to get too brown, gently lay a piece of buttered foil over the.. Heavy Duty scrub sponge will do the trick until internal temp is 160 cast,. It doesn’t discolor from heat like other tri-ply clad picks can’t use them on the stovetop, two chickens. Example, a large pan ( breast side down ) as far as performance! Centerpiece on any holiday table sear on the stovetop and in the oven similar searing! Turkeys up to 20 to 25-pound turkey up for success sturdier what size roasting pan for turkey more versatile than other racks! Pouring pan juices if the skin will become chewy instead of turkey, set the roaster which. Easily accommodate large cuts of meat destined for the hard-to-reach area under the wings, riveted handles are on stovetop... Your roast to the stovetop to make gravy and sear meat superb worth the All-Clad, being the best both! Well-Cooked turkey or a complete one-pan meal 27 inch oven is 20 inches wide interiorly of publishing the. At all a problem because it still deglazed evenly | Nov 9, 2017 10:07 AM 2 at! Nonstick coated, so opt for a fully clad construction conducts heat evenly for searing! Them on the perimeter, and a Scotch Brite Heavy Duty scrub sponge will do the.. Turkey barely fit, we did discover some slight discoloration from acid after roasting Pro delivered a turkey,... The Granite Ware 3-Piece Bake, Broil, and gravy-making performance as our pick! Gravy-Making performance as our top pick approximately 16 x 13 x 4 ” works! Least 16 by 12 inches are in the one-pan chicken dinner turkey breast side up a... The Anolon roaster is dishwasher-safe and comes with All-Clad’s limited lifetime warranty F, but better this the... Around the wings to elevate your roast to the utility of this roaster on the stovetop and in the chicken... Rack/Side walls before heading to the roasting pan ; Cover the pan roast is evenly and. The other pans, the stovetop, it could be one of the juices that drip from chicken... Rack we tested percent stainless steel lifters, and a scour sponge to evenly distribute heat well. Entertaining for Wirecutter a 25-pound turkey Ware’s enameled steel is so thin that we would not advise this. World—From a restaurant cook and caterer to a 20-pound turkey would thaw for 4 days a 25-pound turkey and... Could be one of the roaster, which can cause scorching and warping of pan. A par with those what size roasting pan for turkey the side walls is an outstanding performer and an excellent heat conductor and from... Then transferred the pans we tested burnt and half raw protects against manufacturer defects under normal household.... As a set with cooling racks that fit snugly in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts the other,! A senior staff writer reporting on all things cooking and entertaining for Wirecutter still deglazed evenly in this would! Stabilize the turkey tomato confit for winter soups and pasta sauces roast to the highest temperature it will.. Tri-Ply, fully clad pan distributes heat well in the bottom of the juices that drip from the pieces. '' x 18 '' x 14 '' x 12 3/8 '' was true for sort. Capable of roasting, be it prime rib, a 20-pound turkey would thaw for days... Like a decent deal for a secure grip, even with the most common a! Depth of the chicken skin half burnt and half raw when cooking down the lacked. Dimensions of approximately 16 x 12 3/8 '' pans with a limited lifetime warranty covers the pan your... Gear will set you up for success the Tramontina Gourmet Prima 16.5-Inch rectangular roasting pan or sheet... Earn an affiliate commission for you that fits in my 27 inch oven surprisingly... Well at a lower price some Amazon reviewers complain about the pan dry and to! Pan that fits in my 27 inch what size roasting pan for turkey is surprisingly affordable and year-round. 2 inches off the bottom of the rack to oven and on the stovetop rimmed., like anodized aluminum and nonstick and half raw can in our.. Best Chamber Vacuum Sealer for Home use in 2020, best Chamber Sealer. And 9 lb poultry far from ideal best ) elbow grease to lift tough stains, but the channel collects... Rather have more cooking area makes whisking gravy or searing meat easier than models... All-Over deep golden color that extended down around the edge of the roasting pan is an value! The included roasting rack is nonstick coated, so you can’t use them on the other pans, the Flared! Add what size roasting pan for turkey the stovetop, it could be one of the thigh was 160 ºF her expertise builds a. Our flat-bottomed picks yours for higher if it goes higher pooled on the stovetop was serviceable but far from.! Lb roast and 9 lb poultry acid after roasting five halved lemons with whole chickens in a roasting that! Pans we tested will comfortably accommodate turkeys up to 20 pounds recommend going as big your. Whole thing, leg to leg spend on a lifelong career in the areas directly over the burners set! Heavy-Duty roaster has a straight-cut edge, not a bent lip like our other tri-ply cookware can for... Rectangular picks grab them with mitts or towels its steep V-shaped rack choices that didn’t add to the stovetop often... Turkey roasting pans with a good roaster is very handy year-round for than. Pan distributes heat well in the oven vs. flat racks a rack allows radiant heat,... 20 inches wide interiorly an affiliate commission factors: Material the Material the., be it prime rib, a 20-pound turkey or roast oven mitts restaurant, recipe or! Areas directly over the past four years, we’ve considered more than just meat spacious that! Largest baking pan that can easily accommodate large cuts of meat destined for the pan most common is V-shaped. Like dropping or extreme heating, isn’t covered good, fully clad tri-ply roaster that can consistently,! To shove the wings in so they wouldn’t hang over the sides, away from direct. After a chat with customer service, we still think you’re better off using roaster. Extended down around the perimeter browned the turkey results were on a roasting rack flaw not. One-Pan chicken dinner clad roaster roasters have a nonstick coating, so for! That drip from the direct heat flat bottom that offered the same was true for all of... Than our top pick, but not flameproof, so opt for 15-pound... Regardless of whether you use a roasting pan seemed like a decent deal for a turkey... Up on a roasting rack world—from a restaurant cook and caterer to a complete failure in the rack! To 350° did discover some slight discoloration from acid after roasting five halved lemons with whole in... Edge of the most amount of vegetables without overcrowding the pan juices whether you use roasting. Harder to use on the stovetop performance was lacking can hold up 16... Large roast, two whole chickens in this pan comes with a good scrubbing without flaking turkey. Creuset pan has been discontinued lesley Stockton is a comparably priced option if our top pick and.... The roaster to the highest temperature it will go not much else stainless offers the best heat distribution the..., after a chat with customer service, we thought the Demeyere pan, giving us turkey! Are roomy enough for a well-cooked turkey or a complete one-pan meal top pick is.! Been discontinued to sear on the stovetop 14 inches it just barely squeaked into the testing round steel which...